If you’re baking an apple cake and you don’t have any dark rum on hand, don’t worry!
There are several substitutes that you can use to achieve a similar flavor and texture.
Whether you prefer a non-alcoholic option or you want to experiment with different liquors, there are plenty of alternatives to choose from.
Our article below is packed with lots of ideas for you to try. We’ve done our best to find substitutes that you might have one (or more) of on hand.
Each of these substitutes will give your cake a unique flavor and texture, so feel free to experiment and find your favorite.
With that said, let’s find the right substitute for you!
Why Substitute Dark Rum?
While dark rum adds a unique flavor to apple cake, it is not an essential ingredient. In fact, substituting dark rum can open up new flavor possibilities and make the cake accessible to a wider audience.
Substituting dark rum can also make the recipe more family-friendly, as it eliminates the alcohol content. This is especially important if you are serving the cake to children or to people who do not drink alcohol.
Fruit-Based Substitutes for Dark Rum
Apple Cider
If you’re seeking an alternative to dark rum for your apple cake, apple cider is a prime pick that can cater to your cravings.
Its distinct flavor profile shares a likeness to the boozy counterpart, which can infuse your cake with a gratifyingly fruity essence.
The substitution is simple – just replace the dark rum with an equal amount of apple cider in your recipe.
Alternatively, to intensify the fruity notes, you can simmer the apple cider over a low flame, gradually coaxing out its flavors to create a more condensed consistency.
Pros:
- Has a distinct flavor profile that is similar to dark rum
- Adds a fruity essence to the cake
- Simple substitution, equal amount to replace dark rum
- Can be simmered to intensify the fruity notes and create a more condensed consistency
Cons:
- May not provide the same depth of flavor as dark rum
- May alter the texture of the cake if reduced too much while simmering
Apple Juice
When it comes to replacing dark rum in your apple cake, apple juice is a top-tier option that brings a sweet and fruity essence to the table, perfectly harmonizing with the apple’s natural flavors.
Replacing the dark rum with an equal amount of apple juice is a breeze, just swap it in your recipe.
To intensify the fruity notes and develop a more nuanced taste, simmer the apple juice over low heat to concentrate the flavor.
This trick allows you to craft a more complex and layered flavor profile that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds.
Pros:
- Brings a sweet and fruity essence to the cake
- Complements the natural flavors of the apples
- Simple substitution, equal amount to replace dark rum
- Simmering the apple juice over low heat can intensify the fruity notes and develop a more nuanced taste
- Concentrating the apple juice can create a more complex and layered flavor profile
Cons:
- May not provide the same depth of flavor as dark rum
- May alter the texture of the cake if reduced too much while simmering
Pineapple Juice
Why settle for a standard apple cake when you can add a tropical touch to it?
Pineapple juice can be the perfect substitute for dark rum, elevating your dessert with its signature sweet and tangy taste. The complementary flavors of apples and pineapple juice can create an explosion of flavors in your mouth.
The substitution process is a breeze – swap out the same amount of dark rum with pineapple juice in your recipe. If you’re looking to level up the pineapple taste, gently simmer the juice over low heat to reduce it and thicken the consistency.
This method not only deepens the flavor but also creates a more indulgent and satisfying texture for your cake.
Pros:
- Adds a tropical twist to the apple cake
- Signature sweet and tangy taste that complements the apples
- Simple substitution, equal amount to replace dark rum
- Simmering the pineapple juice over low heat can deepen the flavor and create a more indulgent texture
Cons:
- May not provide the same depth of flavor as dark rum
- May overpower the taste of the apples if not balanced properly
- May not be suitable for those who prefer a more traditional apple cake without tropical flavors
| Substitute | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Apple Cider |
|
|
| Apple Juice |
|
|
| Pineapple Juice |
|
|
Liqueur Substitutes for Dark Rum
Amaretto
Looking for a nutty and sweet twist to your apple cake?
Look no further than Amaretto – the almond-flavored liqueur that can give a flavor boost to your dessert.
With its rich sweetness and complexity, Amaretto can add a new dimension of taste to your apple cake, working in perfect harmony with the apples.
To make the substitution, simply swap out the same amount of dark rum with Amaretto in your recipe.
This little tweak can completely transform your dessert, adding a nutty and subtly bitter note that tantalizes the taste buds.
Pros:
- Adds a nutty and sweet twist to the apple cake
- Rich sweetness and complexity can enhance the flavor of the dessert
- Can work in perfect harmony with the apples
- Simple substitution, equal amount to replace dark rum
- Can add a new dimension of taste to the dessert
Cons:
- May not provide the same depth of flavor as dark rum
- May not be suitable for those with nut allergies
- May not be suitable for those who prefer a more traditional apple cake without nutty flavors
Apricot Brandy
Take your apple cake to the next level by infusing it with a touch of apricot brandy – a fruity and zesty liqueur that can bring a distinctive twist to your dessert.
With its sweet and slightly tart taste, apricot brandy can complement the sweetness of the apples, creating a deliciously harmonious blend of flavors.
Simply replace the same amount of dark rum with apricot brandy in your recipe, and watch as the apricot notes dance on your taste buds.
Whether you’re a fan of fruit-forward desserts or just looking for something different, apricot brandy is a surefire way to add a unique flavor profile to your apple cake.
Pros:
- Fruity and zesty liqueur that can add a distinctive twist to the apple cake
- Sweet and slightly tart taste can complement the sweetness of the apples
- Creates a deliciously harmonious blend of flavors
- Simple substitution, equal amount to replace dark rum
- Can add a unique flavor profile to the dessert
Cons:
- May not provide the same depth of flavor as dark rum
- May not be suitable for those who do not enjoy fruity flavors
- May not be suitable for those who prefer a more traditional apple cake without added fruit flavors
Cherry Liqueur
Add some pizzazz to your dessert with cherry liqueur – a sweet and tangy alternative to dark rum.
With its unique flavor profile, cherry liqueur can create an irresistible flavor combination with apples, giving your taste buds a delightful surprise.
To use it in your recipe, simply swap the same amount of dark rum with cherry liqueur.
You’ll be amazed at how the fruity and slightly tart notes of the liqueur elevate your apple cake to new heights of deliciousness.
Pros:
- Sweet and tangy alternative to dark rum
- Creates an irresistible flavor combination with apples
- Simple substitution, equal amount to replace dark rum
- Can elevate the flavor of the apple cake to new heights
- Adds a unique flavor profile to the dessert
Cons:
- May not provide the same depth of flavor as dark rum
- May not be suitable for those who do not enjoy fruity or tart flavors
- May not be suitable for those who prefer a more traditional apple cake without added fruit flavors
Hazelnut Liqueur
If you’re looking to add a touch of nuttiness to your apple cake, look no further than hazelnut liqueur.
This scrumptious liqueur boasts a sweet and slightly nutty taste that perfectly complements the apples, creating a harmonious flavor explosion.
To make the substitution, simply use an equal amount of hazelnut liqueur in place of the dark rum in your recipe.
The result? A dessert that’s nutty, sweet, and absolutely heavenly.
Pros:
- Hazelnut liqueur can add a unique and nutty flavor to your apple cake that can be a pleasant surprise for your taste buds.
- The sweetness of the liqueur can complement the sweetness of the apples, creating a harmonious balance of flavors.
- It’s easy to substitute with an equal amount of hazelnut liqueur in place of dark rum in your recipe.
Cons:
- The nuttiness of the liqueur might not be preferred by everyone and can be an acquired taste.
- Hazelnut liqueur can be more expensive compared to other substitutes for dark rum.
- The flavor might not pair well with other ingredients or toppings in your apple cake, so it’s important to consider the overall flavor profile before making the substitution.
Orange Liqueur (such as Grand Marnier or Cointreau)
Hold on to your hats, folks – we’ve got a real wild card ingredient for your apple cake!
Introducing orange liqueur – the citrusy and slightly sweet flavor that’s sure to make your taste buds pay attention.
With its unique taste profile, orange liqueur can bring a whole new dimension to your apple cake, complementing the apples in a way that’ll make your head spin.
To use it as a substitute for dark rum, simply swap in the same amount of orange liqueur in your recipe.
Pros:
- Orange liqueur can add a unique citrusy and slightly sweet flavor to your apple cake, making it stand out from traditional apple cakes.
- It can complement the apple flavors in a unique and unexpected way, providing a pleasant surprise to your taste buds.
- The substitution process is easy – just swap in the same amount of orange liqueur for dark rum in your recipe.
Cons:
- Some people may not enjoy the combination of citrus and apple flavors in their dessert.
- The flavor of the orange liqueur may not be as versatile in other recipes compared to dark rum.
Peach Schnapps
A luscious and fruity addition to your apple cake awaits!
Enter peach schnapps – a sweet and slightly tangy liqueur that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds.
Its unique taste profile can complement the apples in a way that’s simply divine. To make the substitution, simply use an equal amount of peach schnapps in place of dark rum in your recipe.
You’ll be amazed at how the peach notes weave themselves into the already delicious flavors of the apple cake, creating a dessert that’s simply unforgettable.
Pros:
- Peach schnapps can add a fruity and tangy flavor to your apple cake, creating a unique taste profile.
- It can complement the sweetness of the apples and create a well-balanced dessert.
- It’s a simple substitution – just replace the same amount of dark rum with peach schnapps in your recipe.
Cons:
- The peach flavor may overpower the apple flavor if too much is used.
- It may not work well with certain flavor combinations or if you prefer a traditional apple cake taste.
- Some may not enjoy the taste of peach schnapps, making it an acquired taste for some.
| Substitute | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Amaretto | Adds nutty and sweet twist, enhances flavor, simple substitution | May not provide same depth of flavor, may not be suitable for those with nut allergies or prefer traditional apple cake without nutty flavors |
| Apricot Brandy | Fruity and zesty, adds a distinctive twist, simple substitution | May not provide same depth of flavor, may not be suitable for those who do not enjoy fruity flavors or prefer traditional apple cake without added fruit flavors |
| Cherry Liqueur | Sweet and tangy, creates irresistible flavor combination, simple substitution | May not provide same depth of flavor, may not be suitable for those who do not enjoy fruity or tart flavors, or prefer traditional apple cake without added fruit flavors |
| Hazelnut Liqueur | Adds a unique and nutty flavor, complements apples, simple substitution | Nuttiness might not be preferred by everyone, may be more expensive, flavor might not pair well with other ingredients or toppings |
| Orange Liqueur (such as Grand Marnier or Cointreau) | Adds unique citrusy and slightly sweet flavor, complements apple flavors, simple substitution | Some may not enjoy the combination of citrus and apple flavors, flavor may not be as versatile in other recipes compared to dark rum |
| Peach Schnapps | Adds fruity and tangy flavor, complements the sweetness of the apples, simple substitution | Peach flavor may overpower apple flavor if too much is used, may not work well with certain flavor combinations or if you prefer a traditional apple cake taste, some may not enjoy the taste of peach schnapps |
Spirit Substitutes for Dark Rum
Brandy
In the world of apple cake, brandy is the dark horse that can take your dessert to new heights.
Why? Well, for starters, it boasts a similar flavor profile to dark rum, with its warm and fruity taste tinged with hints of vanilla and caramel.
To use brandy as a substitute for dark rum in your apple cake recipe, simply swap out the same amount of dark rum with brandy. It’s that easy!
So the next time you’re baking an apple cake and don’t have dark rum on hand, don’t fret – brandy is here to save the day.
Pros:
- Brandy has a similar flavor profile to dark rum, so it can provide a comparable taste to your apple cake.
- It’s made from distilled wine, which can add complexity to your dessert.
- Brandy has a warm, fruity taste with hints of vanilla and caramel, which can complement the flavors of the apples in your cake.
- It’s easy to use as a substitute – just replace the same amount of dark rum with brandy in your recipe.
Cons:
- Brandy is not as commonly found in households as other ingredients, so you may need to purchase it specifically for this substitution.
- Its strong taste may not appeal to everyone’s palate, so be aware of your guests’ preferences before using it in your dessert.
Coconut Rum
Want to give your apple cake a tropical makeover? Look no further than coconut rum – the sweet and flavorful liquor that can add a touch of the tropics to your dessert.
With its deliciously sweet coconut taste, coconut rum can be a game-changer when used as a substitute for dark rum in apple cake recipes.
Simply swap out the same amount of dark rum with coconut rum to get that tropical twist you’re looking for.
The pairing of coconut and apple may seem unconventional, but trust us – it’s a match made in heaven that’ll have your taste buds doing the hula dance.
Pros:
- Coconut rum adds a sweet and tropical flavor to apple cake, giving it a unique twist
- It pairs well with the apple’s natural flavors, creating a harmonious blend of tastes
- It’s easy to use as a substitute – just replace the same amount of dark rum with coconut rum in your recipe
Cons:
- Coconut rum may not be to everyone’s taste, especially those who don’t like the flavor of coconut
- It can overpower the other flavors in the recipe if too much is used
| Liqueur | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Brandy | Similar flavor profile to dark rum, warm and fruity taste with hints of vanilla and caramel, adds complexity to the dessert, easy to substitute | May not be as commonly found in households, strong taste may not appeal to everyone’s palate |
| Coconut Rum | Adds a sweet and tropical flavor to apple cake, easy to substitute | May not be to everyone’s taste, can overpower other flavors if too much is used |
Sweetener Substitutes for Dark Rum
Caramel Sauce
Caramel sauce is the unsung hero of the baking world – it’s the secret ingredient that can take your apple cake from good to great.
With its rich and buttery taste, caramel sauce can add a depth of flavor to your dessert that’s simply divine. You can either make your own by melting sugar in a saucepan and adding butter and cream, or you can save time and buy it pre-made at the store.
To use caramel sauce as a substitute for dark rum in your apple cake recipe, simply replace 1/4 cup of rum with 1/4 cup of caramel sauce.
Pros:
- Caramel sauce adds a rich and buttery taste to apple cake that can enhance its flavor profile.
- It’s easy to make at home or can be purchased pre-made at the store.
- Caramel sauce can add a new level of depth to apple cake that dark rum may not provide.
Cons:
- Using caramel sauce as a substitute for dark rum may alter the texture and consistency of the cake, as the sauce is a liquid and the rum is not.
- The sweetness of the caramel sauce may overpower the other flavors in the cake if not used in moderation.
- Those with lactose intolerance or dairy allergies may not be able to enjoy caramel sauce.
Cinnamon Syrup
Cinnamon syrup is a sneaky little ingredient that can add a spicy kick to your apple cake, taking it from ordinary to extraordinary.
You can create your own cinnamon syrup by simmering cinnamon sticks in water and sugar, or you can grab a bottle of pre-made syrup from the store.
To use cinnamon syrup as a substitute for dark rum in your apple cake recipe, simply swap out 1/4 cup of rum with 1/4 cup of cinnamon syrup.
Pros:
- Adds a warm and spicy flavor to your apple cake.
- Cinnamon is a popular and beloved spice that pairs well with apples.
- Can be easily made at home or bought pre-made at the store.
Cons:
- Not everyone may enjoy the spicy flavor profile.
- May not work well in all apple cake recipes, as some may require the sweetness of dark rum.
- Pre-made cinnamon syrups may contain artificial flavors or additives.
Maple Syrup
Maple syrup is the golden nectar that can add a delightful twist to your apple cake, infusing it with a sweet and earthy flavor that’s hard to resist.
Whether you prefer pure maple syrup or the maple-flavored variety, this delicious ingredient can take your dessert to new heights.
To use maple syrup as a substitute for dark rum in your apple cake recipe, simply replace 1/4 cup of rum with 1/4 cup of maple syrup. It’s that easy!
Pros:
- Adds a sweet and earthy flavor to your apple cake
- Can be used in place of pure or maple-flavored syrup
- Easy to use as a substitute for dark rum
Cons:
- May not be suitable for those who don’t like sweet desserts
- Can make the apple cake slightly more dense and moist than with dark rum
| Ingredient | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Caramel Sauce |
|
|
| Cinnamon Syrup |
|
|
| Maple Syrup |
|
|
Extract Substitutes for Dark Rum
Vanilla Extract
Looking for a non-alcoholic option to flavor your apple cake? Look no further than vanilla extract – a household staple with a sweet and cozy flavor that’s perfect for enhancing your dessert.
To use vanilla extract as a substitute for dark rum in your recipe, mix one tablespoon of vanilla extract with two tablespoons of water. This will replace the liquid volume of rum and give your cake a deliciously warm and sweet undertone.
Pros:
- Vanilla extract is a common household ingredient that’s easy to find in local stores.
- It’s a non-alcoholic option, making it suitable for those who prefer not to consume alcohol.
- Vanilla extract has a sweet and warm flavor that complements the apple cake well.
Cons:
- Vanilla extract doesn’t have the same depth of flavor as dark rum, so the resulting cake may not have the same complexity of flavor.
- The substitution may alter the texture of the cake, as the liquid volume is being replaced with water.
Rum Extract
Rum extract is a flavor-packed ingredient that can be a lifesaver when you’re out of dark rum but still want that signature taste and aroma in your recipes.
This concentrated extract can mimic the flavor of rum without the alcohol content, making it a versatile ingredient for cakes, drinks, and other recipes.
To use rum extract as a substitute for dark rum in your apple cake recipe, simply replace 2 tablespoons of rum with 1.5 tablespoons of rum extract. This will give you the same rich and delicious flavor that you would get from using dark rum.
Pros:
- Provides the same rich and delicious flavor as dark rum without the alcohol content
- Versatile ingredient for various recipes, including cakes and drinks
- Concentrated flavor allows for more precise measurements and control over the intensity of the flavor
Cons:
- May not provide the same depth of flavor as using actual dark rum
- Some people may not enjoy the artificial taste of the extract
- Can be difficult to find in some stores
| Option | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Vanilla Extract | Common household ingredient, non-alcoholic option, sweet and warm flavor that complements apple cake well | Doesn’t have the same depth of flavor as dark rum, substitution may alter cake texture, resulting cake may not have same complexity of flavor |
| Rum Extract | Provides same rich and delicious flavor as dark rum without the alcohol content, versatile ingredient for various recipes, concentrated flavor allows for more precise measurements and control over the intensity of the flavor | May not provide the same depth of flavor as using actual dark rum, some people may not enjoy the artificial taste of the extract, can be difficult to find in some stores |
Hiya! I’m Kimberly, a contributing writer here at Miss Buttercup. I was born and raised in the UP, Michigan’s Upper Peninsula for those who don’t know, the land of beautiful, beach-filled sunny summer days and bone-chilling long winters. Growing up there made me appreciate all the little things about life, especially the way a delicious meal can bring people closer together. I try and put that same feeling into each article I write and I hope it comes across that way!
